議論 » Greasy Fork镜像 への意見

Antifeature ads should have several classifications

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20
編集日: 2025/06/20

Good day.

From the discussion with hacker09, I would advise to consider to add types of "ads", because the references of my Newspaper for Greasemonkey extension are for educational purposes, not commercial.

And the description "This script will inject ads on the sites you visit." is either untrue or too extreme to that extension.

Please advise.

Kind regards,

Schimon

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20
編集日: 2025/06/20

Hi Schimon,
your script clearly lists feeds that are useful for the user. Of course, if someone paid you to add some of these links, we can't know, but I think that referral-linkand ads antifeature tags already cover the possible misuses of links.
The description "This script will inject ads on the sites you visit." refers to scripts that have a purpose and then show ads that are not directly related to fulfilling that purpose. In your case, listing feeds is exactly the purpose of your script.
Do you have a specific suggestion for a new tag?

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20

P.S. in my opinion the antifeatures tag should serve to protect the users from the greed or the malicious intents of some developers, and I don't see any of these in your script.

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20
編集日: 2025/06/20

Do you have a specific suggestion for a new tag?

I do not know.

Promotions, and Referrals would be conceived as advertisements.

Perhaps we can allocate levels or rates from 1 - 3.

Maybe "ref" for references would be appropriate.

P.S. in my opinion the antifeatures tag should serve to protect the users from the greed or the malicious intents of some developers, and I don't see any of these in your script.

Thank you. Then, may I remove the antifeature metablock from my script?

It is important for me to not have anifeature metablocks because this script was created as a mean of protest against the people who suppress RSS, and anifeature metablocks discourage installations.

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20

I have removed the metablock aftre a moderator has dismissed a claim.

https://greasyforks.org/en/scripts/465932-newspaper-syndication-feed-reader/diff?v1=1610764&v2=1610704

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20

I think, that "Political" might be a good label.

My script is politically super-charged for syndicated technologies.

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20

Sounds like an interesting feature, not only saying "ads" but knowing which type, this could increase script installs, like if users hate ads they wouldn't install the script at all, but if even though they hate ads, but don't mind seeing only and specifically political ads, maybe because the like politic topics, then they would install the script anyway.

§
投稿日: 2025/06/20
編集日: 2025/06/20

Yes.

I suppose so.

Good day! I am a lawayer, and I have created that software because I am concerned of this and that, and I have also included related resources and references.

This seems fine to me.

We can experiment and see how it progresses.

返信を投稿

返信を投稿するにはログインしてください

长期地址
遇到问题?请前往 GitHub 提 Issues。